Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mat Cusick's avatar

Interesting article and very important discussion. I look forward to reading the book. However, I must take issue with the claim that ALU “had neither the capacity nor organizing vision to onboard” workers reaching out after the election victory. As one of he leaders of that particular project at that time, I must correct you that there was a vision and there was capacity, but that Chris Smalls deliberately dismantled it and prevented the capacity from being deployed and the vision from being fulfilled. This fact has mostly been covered up, but it was reported at the time (albeit superficially): https://time.com/6197364/amazon-union-pauses-nyc-campaign/#

Over the past 3 years, a lot of poor analysis has been drawn from a misunderstanding of what happened immediately after the JFK8 election victory—namely, a systematic internal dismantling of organizing capacity by Chris Smalls and a few loyalists to centralize and maintain his grip on power (which required legal intervention and the organizing of a democratic caucus to extricate the union from). Any narrative of that campaign that doesn’t include this essential truth will only mislead people about what the actual shortcomings of the independent union were and why it failed. (The poor conclusions of Erik Loomis about ALU and the viability of independent unions, for instance: https://newlaborforum.cuny.edu/2023/04/28/independent-unions-the-allure-of-a-failing-strategy/)

Expand full comment

No posts