My research found that 25 of the party’s 32 Senate candidates explicitly ran against the billionaire class. When Third Way says moderates won Democrats their majorities, they’re confused or lying.
I agree with this as far as it goes, but I think the bigger question is, how do we restore faith in the idea that our problems are addressable, let alone solvable? It might be worth winning a few races by a smaller margin in order to elect people who have a strong mandate to actually do worthwhile things that in the long run everyone will appreciate (e.g. Medicare for All, a strong transition to the clean-energy future, sustained adequate revenue for the government through higher marginal tax rates on the rich). Just being in charge for a few years and tinkering around the edges hasn't gotten us the kind of durable governing majority that the Democrats had for the years following the New Deal. That's what we should be aspiring to. We need to win to get it, and that may require *some* candidates to use more moderate language, but we need leaders who will push the Party to do big things, and if they wind up winning by smaller margins than a more wishy-washy candidate would, that's fine. Note that I'm not being anti-majoritarian here - Medicare for All has majority support in the US, and El-Sayed had a clear majority in Michigan!
Just posted this on FB, but if you want to respond here, it's probably the better medium. Appreciate all you do Eric.
I know your writing is in good faith, so please don’t read this as a knock on your motives. But I think this piece falls short of the honest postmortem you’ve rightly called on the left to do. The subtitle says 25 of 32 candidates “explicitly ran against the billionaire class,” but the evidence is that the word appeared on their campaign websites. That’s not the same thing, and your own caveats acknowledge it, so why state it so strongly up front?
Your conclusion, that anti-billionaire rhetoric is compatible with winning in a year when anti-Trump backlash was the main driver, seems right to me. It’s a good answer to the claim that moderates alone made the majority. But it doesn’t answer the more specific claim in the Third Way memo: that El-Sayed, Flanagan, and Jackson ran about 5 points behind their party’s statewide House vote (Jackson by 10), and behind the moderate governor candidates on the same ballot. Those gaps could have many explanations, like candidate quality, spending, or local factors, and I’d genuinely like to see you take them on. Without that, the piece pushes back on the weaker version of their argument and leaves the crux unaddressed.
Corporate mass media, being an oligarchy, was back at work manufacturing consent for the political duopoly. They don't need censorship and evidently there is too much wealth and power at stake to resort to independent journalism, a keystone to a healthy democracy.
I agree with this as far as it goes, but I think the bigger question is, how do we restore faith in the idea that our problems are addressable, let alone solvable? It might be worth winning a few races by a smaller margin in order to elect people who have a strong mandate to actually do worthwhile things that in the long run everyone will appreciate (e.g. Medicare for All, a strong transition to the clean-energy future, sustained adequate revenue for the government through higher marginal tax rates on the rich). Just being in charge for a few years and tinkering around the edges hasn't gotten us the kind of durable governing majority that the Democrats had for the years following the New Deal. That's what we should be aspiring to. We need to win to get it, and that may require *some* candidates to use more moderate language, but we need leaders who will push the Party to do big things, and if they wind up winning by smaller margins than a more wishy-washy candidate would, that's fine. Note that I'm not being anti-majoritarian here - Medicare for All has majority support in the US, and El-Sayed had a clear majority in Michigan!
Just posted this on FB, but if you want to respond here, it's probably the better medium. Appreciate all you do Eric.
I know your writing is in good faith, so please don’t read this as a knock on your motives. But I think this piece falls short of the honest postmortem you’ve rightly called on the left to do. The subtitle says 25 of 32 candidates “explicitly ran against the billionaire class,” but the evidence is that the word appeared on their campaign websites. That’s not the same thing, and your own caveats acknowledge it, so why state it so strongly up front?
Your conclusion, that anti-billionaire rhetoric is compatible with winning in a year when anti-Trump backlash was the main driver, seems right to me. It’s a good answer to the claim that moderates alone made the majority. But it doesn’t answer the more specific claim in the Third Way memo: that El-Sayed, Flanagan, and Jackson ran about 5 points behind their party’s statewide House vote (Jackson by 10), and behind the moderate governor candidates on the same ballot. Those gaps could have many explanations, like candidate quality, spending, or local factors, and I’d genuinely like to see you take them on. Without that, the piece pushes back on the weaker version of their argument and leaves the crux unaddressed.
Corporate mass media, being an oligarchy, was back at work manufacturing consent for the political duopoly. They don't need censorship and evidently there is too much wealth and power at stake to resort to independent journalism, a keystone to a healthy democracy.
This is a tell.