Timely and clear analysis. Good translating, Eric! This is the kind of thing that a DSA publication should be putting out on a regular basis about current events in the US.
No mention of the Amazon. A Bolsonaro win in the second round will hasten the death of the Brazilian Amazon and therefore of human civilization, and many Brazilians seem to be unaware or in denial about this.
I have very similar feelings with Colombia's recent elections as well. Petro was one of the best presidents Colombia has had, especially being the first left wing leader after 200 years of right wing rule. But regardless of that, he also only played within the limits that the majority of the conservative congress imposes on him. He could have expedited amendments to the constitution, and used more executive orders to govern, but he didn't.
His utter respect for the landscape that was laid before him prevented us Colombians from having his labor, pension and health reforms take place. Leftist leaders cannot play within the bounds of liberal democracies anymore.
Agreed. Has implications also for what kind of administration we'd need if AOC gets elected. People are too fed up with status quo for us to just tinker around the edges
Sadly the social media effect is still a huge threat to democracy (not only in Brasil but across the world). The amount of fake news coming through on feeds was staggering before and during the election itself.
We watched with despair as the result of the first round became more clear. Indeed there is a lot to be done to turn the sentiment around for the second round.
There’s a lot to be said about bringing along a sense of community and directly reaching out to right wing voters to understand the reason behind their vote and making a real change.
Asking whether Lula could have won or not in 2026 is to miss the real underlying problem in Brazil—the PT hasn't been able to develop a national figure with nearly the same popularity and pull as Lula. Remember, Lula stepped aside in 2018 so Fernando Haddad could run at the top of the ticket. And then Haddad lost to Bolsonaro, so Lula returned at the young spry age of 77 in 2022 to save Brazilian democracy from a guy who, after Lula beat him, tried to stage a coup but was stopped by his own generals.
Perhaps the closest analogue in American socialist history to the PT's predicament is when Eugene Debs decided not to run for president in 1916 on the Socialist Party ticket and the party's vote share was cut almost in half, falling in absolute terms from 901,551 votes to just 585,113 votes. When Debs died a decade later, so did the SP as a force in American politics. MAS in neighboring Bolivia recently imploded and disappeared because it too could not get beyond the singular figure of Evo Morales.
Too often leftists fall into the trap of thinking that election results are *primarily* about policy or Big Ideas (socialism, capitalism, communism, fascism, etc.) and neglect the factors that are far more influential from a voter behavior perspective—personas and their associated brands/vibes. Lula is 80 years old and the right successfully exploited that vulnerability by running Bolsonaro's son who is just 45, creating a very stark contrast that played into and reinforced the old/establishment vs. young/insurgent trope. It's also worth remembering that during the 2022 campaign Lula promised that he would not run for re-election in response to concerns people had back then about the age issue.
The trouble with this article is that it only talks about policy and doesn't address why, as the author put it, "Lula finally woke up in September 2026." Age is almost certainly a factor in why it took so long for him to 'wake up' and why his 2022-2026 administration lacked the vigor and ambition of his previous terms in office (2003-2011).
Timely and clear analysis. Good translating, Eric! This is the kind of thing that a DSA publication should be putting out on a regular basis about current events in the US.
No mention of the Amazon. A Bolsonaro win in the second round will hasten the death of the Brazilian Amazon and therefore of human civilization, and many Brazilians seem to be unaware or in denial about this.
I have very similar feelings with Colombia's recent elections as well. Petro was one of the best presidents Colombia has had, especially being the first left wing leader after 200 years of right wing rule. But regardless of that, he also only played within the limits that the majority of the conservative congress imposes on him. He could have expedited amendments to the constitution, and used more executive orders to govern, but he didn't.
His utter respect for the landscape that was laid before him prevented us Colombians from having his labor, pension and health reforms take place. Leftist leaders cannot play within the bounds of liberal democracies anymore.
Agreed. Has implications also for what kind of administration we'd need if AOC gets elected. People are too fed up with status quo for us to just tinker around the edges
Good piece.
Sadly the social media effect is still a huge threat to democracy (not only in Brasil but across the world). The amount of fake news coming through on feeds was staggering before and during the election itself.
We watched with despair as the result of the first round became more clear. Indeed there is a lot to be done to turn the sentiment around for the second round.
There’s a lot to be said about bringing along a sense of community and directly reaching out to right wing voters to understand the reason behind their vote and making a real change.
Asking whether Lula could have won or not in 2026 is to miss the real underlying problem in Brazil—the PT hasn't been able to develop a national figure with nearly the same popularity and pull as Lula. Remember, Lula stepped aside in 2018 so Fernando Haddad could run at the top of the ticket. And then Haddad lost to Bolsonaro, so Lula returned at the young spry age of 77 in 2022 to save Brazilian democracy from a guy who, after Lula beat him, tried to stage a coup but was stopped by his own generals.
Perhaps the closest analogue in American socialist history to the PT's predicament is when Eugene Debs decided not to run for president in 1916 on the Socialist Party ticket and the party's vote share was cut almost in half, falling in absolute terms from 901,551 votes to just 585,113 votes. When Debs died a decade later, so did the SP as a force in American politics. MAS in neighboring Bolivia recently imploded and disappeared because it too could not get beyond the singular figure of Evo Morales.
Too often leftists fall into the trap of thinking that election results are *primarily* about policy or Big Ideas (socialism, capitalism, communism, fascism, etc.) and neglect the factors that are far more influential from a voter behavior perspective—personas and their associated brands/vibes. Lula is 80 years old and the right successfully exploited that vulnerability by running Bolsonaro's son who is just 45, creating a very stark contrast that played into and reinforced the old/establishment vs. young/insurgent trope. It's also worth remembering that during the 2022 campaign Lula promised that he would not run for re-election in response to concerns people had back then about the age issue.
The trouble with this article is that it only talks about policy and doesn't address why, as the author put it, "Lula finally woke up in September 2026." Age is almost certainly a factor in why it took so long for him to 'wake up' and why his 2022-2026 administration lacked the vigor and ambition of his previous terms in office (2003-2011).